Legitimacy and Implications of Reducing Colletotrichum kahawae to Subspecies in Plant Pathology

Colletotrichum kahawae Waller and Bridge is a highly aggressive and specialized fungal pathogen of coffee, causing the devastating Coffee Berry Disease (CBD), particularly at high altitudes. The disease arises from the unique ability of the pathogen to infect green developing coffee berries. This pathogen is currently confined to the African continent in all countries that grow Arabica coffee (Coffea arabica L.), leading to up to 80% yield losses, if no control measures are applied (Silva et al. For such huge economic impact, it is ranked as a quarantine pathogen and even as a biological weapon (Australia Group, 2014). Consequently, the pathogen's potential dispersal to other Arabica coffee cultivation regions is greatly feared, particularly to those at high altitude also found in Latin America and Asia. Recently, this recognized species was brought down to a subspecific level (C. kahawae subsp. kahawae) based on molecular data (Weir et al., 2012), clustering together with a generalist and cosmopolitan group of Colletotrichum isolates unable to cause CBD (C. kahawae subsp. ciggaro). Since then a growing number of studies have reported the identification of C. kahawae in various hosts and regions of the Although these reports are referring to C. kahawae subsp. ciggaro, some of them could not distinguish the pathogen at the subspecific level, and this is leading to a wave of confusion of whether the long accepted species C. kahawae, the CBD pathogen, has escaped from Africa and extended its host range. Given the extreme impact that this situation may trigger and the subsequent biosecurity implications, there is a practical need to completely distinguish these pathogens taxonomically as to avoid the risk of misidentification, and caution should be taken on assigning/reassigning taxonomic ranking and nomenclature. Here we consider the evidences sustaining and contradicting the classification proposed by Weir et al. (2012), and discuss the risks and practical implications of changing the CBD pathogen's species status in a plant pathology context. After a long period of confusion in nomenclature, Colletotrichum kahawae (epithet derived from the Swahili word for coffee) was proposed by Waller et al. (1993) as a formal name to refer specifically to Colletotrichum isolates causing CBD and taxonomically distinguishing them from other Colletotrichum strains found on coffee. The CBD pathogen was previously known as either C. coffeanum var. Interestingly, the name C. coffeanum was not based on type material associated with CBD, but on samples from Brazil where the disease does not …